Skip to content
Chronological Reasoning and Causation

Women's Rights in Early New York

  1. Load Excerpt of State of New York Chapter 200 of the Laws of 1848, Property Rights of Married Women in Main Image Viewer
  2. Load Excerpt of State of New York Chapter 200 of the Laws of 1848, Property Rights of Married Women in Main Image Viewer
  3. Load Excerpt of Chapter 216 of the Colonial Laws, Women and Property Rights, 1710 in Main Image Viewer
  4. Load Excerpt of Chapter 216 of the Colonial Laws, Women and Property Rights, 1710 in Main Image Viewer
  5. Load Excerpt of Chapter 216 of the Colonial Laws, Women and Property Rights, 1710 in Main Image Viewer
  6. Load Petition by the Heirs of Samuel Palmer of Westchester on Behalf of His Widow, 1670 in Main Image Viewer
  7. Load Petition by the Heirs of Samuel Palmer of Westchester on Behalf of His Widow, 1670 in Main Image Viewer
  8. Load Excerpt from the Marriage Contract of Brant Peelen and Marritje Pieters, 1643 in Main Image Viewer
  9. Load Excerpt from the Marriage Contract of Brant Peelen and Marritje Pieters, 1643 in Main Image Viewer
  10. Load Excerpt from the Marriage Contract of Brant Peelen and Marritje Pieters, 1643 in Main Image Viewer

Suggested Teaching Instructions

Historical Context
New York State bears the imprint of both its Dutch and English colonial past.  Despite the conquest of New Netherland by the English in 1664, the impact of Dutch culture and religion, as well as the influence of New Netherlands’ most powerful families could still be felt centuries later.  Likewise, Dutch legal traditions endured in parts of colonial New York for nearly a century following the English take-over.

Gradually, the English replaced Dutch laws with practices rooted in English common law and English colonial experiences in North America.  Women were among those most profoundly affected by changes in the legal system.  Under Dutch law, married women could retain control over property they possessed prior to marriage, buy and sell property, make contracts including ante-nuptial agreements, write wills, and appear in court on their own behalf.  Widows were entitled to inherit at least half of the marital estate, with the remaining portion being divided equally among children regardless of gender.  Consequently, both single and married women in New Netherland found opportunities for economic independence and prosperity.
    
Under English law, women surrendered control over property upon marriage and could not enter into contracts, write wills, or initiate legal action without consent or participation of their husbands.  A widow's legal inheritance was limited in most cases to one-third of the marital estate and most fathers favored sons over daughters in wills involving real property.  Gradually, English laws affecting property began to significantly curtail the participation of women in business and trade.  In 1710, the colonial assembly equated women with minors and those "not of Sound mind" in an act specifying requirements for obtaining legal title to land.  It was not until more than seven decades after independence that New York State returned some of the rights that women had enjoyed under Dutch rule.

 
Essential Question
How are the rights of citizens determined by a society?
 
Check for Understanding
Explain the difference in women's rights under Dutch and English law.