Skip to content
Teaching the Holocaust and other Genocides
 
Created in collaboration with the Holocaust & Human Rights Center, the NYS Education Department, and the NYS Archives Partnership Trust.

Rudolf Brazda

The son of Czech immigrants, Rudolf Brazda was bRudolf Brazda.pngorn on June 26, 1913, in the village of Brossen, near the town of Meuselwitz, about thirty miles southwest of Leipzig. After finishing school, he aspired to become a window dresser but instead secured an apprenticeship as a roofer. He was also an active member of a communist youth organization.

In 1933, Rudolf met sales assistant Fritz Werner Bilz at the Mumsdorf public outdoor pool and instantly fell in love. Recalling their first encounter, Rudolf later said:
 

"All of a sudden, I saw this beautiful young man. I was almost mad, you could say. He was standing there in front of the pool, wearing a long bathrobe, and I thought, how could I possibly get to know him? Should I talk to him? I ran up to him, but I couldn't find the words. So, I just pushed him into the water. As he swam, the weight of the wet bathrobe pulled him down. Luckily, I was able to grab him right away and pull him out. He laughed more than he cried and didn't blame me—maybe he liked me, too. That turned out to be the case. We went into the locker room together, into the showers. I dried him off with a towel, and he liked that. I asked him what he was doing that night, and he said, 'I don't know, do you want to meet up?'"

Thus began their relationship, and the two became a couple. Werner was born on April 26, 1914, in Limbach, Saxony. After training as a sales assistant, he moved to Meuselwitz in 1931, where he worked for a men's outfitter.

From March 1934 until Werner was drafted into the Wehrmacht (German military) in the fall of 1936, they lived together as subtenants with the widow Helene Mahrenholz, a Jehovah’s Witness. Their apartment soon became the center of a circle of gay friends who went together on excursions and had parties with card games and dancing. To seal their friendship, Rudolf and Werner even celebrated a” wedding” and did not only invite their friends, but also some relatives. “It was not really meant to be serious; it was all done in a humorous sense. … We didn't want a serious ceremony; we just wanted to have a nice time. We simply had a nice, fun celebration with this wedding.”

Then, police arrested Werner for the first time on August 3, 1935, during a raid in Meerane, a town south of Meuselwitz. The occasion was a friend’s birthday celebration in the “Kaffee Altmarkt.” Friends from Meuselwitz joined Werner, including Reinhold Winter. All of them were looking forward to a great evening, and it really became a high-spirited party. But, at around nine o'clock in the evening, officers from the Criminal Investigation Department (CID) appeared and as a later report indicated “broke up” the party. Some of them escaped, but the CID arrested ten people, including the host. After intensive questioning, the CID released them. According to a police report, the Meuselwitz friends all admitted “their same-sex orientation.” Back in Meuselwitz, the local police further interrogated Werner, but there was no follow-up.

The police targeted their friend Reinhold Winter, a locksmith, in the spring of 1937. The lively Reinhold knew many gay people from all over Germany and was a member of the “Bund homosexueller Freunde” (League of Homosexual Friends) and police arrested him for the first time on March 18, 1933, during a raid against this association. Although Reinhold denied most of the acts he was accused of, he was sentenced to three years in prison by the Altenburg district court on August 6, 1937 in accordance with § 175.[1] Reinhold appealed and the “Reichsgericht” (Reich’s court) finally reduced his sentence to two years and three months which he served in Ichtershausen (Thuringia, Germany) and St. Georgen (Baden-Wurtemberg, Germany) prisons until November 9, 1939.  What happened afterwards with him is unclear. On July 31, 1949, the Altenburg district court declared him dead.

As a result of Reinhold’s arrest, police targeted Rudolf and Werner's entire circle of friends, and on April 7, 1937, they arrested Rudolf in accordance with § 175. In May the Altenburg district court sentenced him to six months in prison. After serving his sentence, Germany expelled him. From a legal and technical point of view, they considered him a Czechoslovak citizen with a criminal record and, as such, treated as persona non grata in Nazi Germany and made to leave the country. Because his parents had not taught him Czech, he left for what was technically his country, but opted to settle in the German-speaking region of Sudetenland, the westernmost province of Czechoslovakia, So Rudolf went to Karlsbad. In the beginning he earned a living as a soap salesperson. Later, he earned his money performing Josephine Baker imitations[2] and traveled through Bohemia with a Jewish theater troupe.

After Rudolf's conviction, proceedings against Werner began at the Weimar Air Force Court. Although the outcome is unknown, it is highly likely that the convicted Werner under § 175. Because Rudolf’s exile, the two did not meet again until a few years later, after the occupation of the Sudetenland at the occasion of a party in Rudolf’s hometown of Limbach. The two of them danced together, but by then, Werner had found a new boyfriend, and their relationship was not reestablished. Werner died on the Eastern Front in 1943, in Romania. They declared him dead on December 31, 1949.

Rudolf’s new boyfriend was Anton “Toni” Hartl, who was born in 1916 in Schönbach (Bohemia, Czechoslovakia). His father was a master baker and ran his own confectionery. He had died when Hartl was sixteen years old. After completing school, Toni trained as a hairdresser and in the summer of 1938, he was employed by a master hairdresser of the “Westböhmische Volksbühne” (Western Bohemia Peoples’ Stage), known as the “Fischli-Bühne” (Fischli Stage). This was a theater troupe of mostly Jewish refugees that gave performances in the German-speaking parts of Bohemia and happened to be the theatre troupe with whom Werner was traveling.

At the end of August 1938, the Fischli Stage was performing in Sodau, five kilometers north of Karlsbad, when the actors’ hairdresser, Toni met the stagehand, Rudolf.

A few days later, the two celebrated Toni’s 22nd birthday. “Once we were outside; it was dark, and suddenly, because I saw he fancied me, I took him in my arms and kissed him. From then on, he was “on fire for me.” Rudolf and Toni became inseparable. Toni wooed Rudolf, invited him on excursions to various places and surprised him with little gifts.

After the German annexation of Czechoslovakia, in October 1938, the Fischli Stage was dissolved and the two moved to Karlsbad, where Toni worked as a hairdresser and supported Rudolf who was now unemployed. The two moved into two attic rooms opposite each other, which they used as an apartment due to their increasing fears. Rudolf, in particular, who had a criminal record, knew exactly how dangerous the situation was.

These worries turned to reality for Rudolf. The Karlsbad criminal investigation department (CID) received a tip that set an extensive investigation in motion. On New Year’s Eve 1940 the CID received a handwritten letter that brought to the attention of the police a person from Rudolf's circle of friends in Karlsbad: “I would like to draw your attention to the fact that a ‘warmer Bruder’ (warm brother)[3] named Josef Nawrocki lives with us in the Reichsadler house and only received visits from gentlemen and is also overly friendly with the residents of the house…. Heil Hitler. Julius Lohwasser.”

During this investigation, police arrested Rudolf on April 1, 1941. On May 7, Toni, who had joined the army in the meantime, was also arrested and first imprisoned in Regensburg, Bavaria. Then, at the end of May he was transferred to the court prison in Eger where a second the trial took place. Toni tried to absPrisoner ID Card for Rudolf Brazda.jpgolve himself by pointing out that “in Czech times” such offenses were “not prosecuted so severely.” However, this argument did not convince the court, and they convicted Toni, Rudolf and two other defendants under § 175.

Rudolf received the harshest sentence of fourteen months in prison; because of his previous conviction, the court viewed him as a “repeat offender” and “seducer.” The government accused him of “seducing” Toni. Toni received a lighter sentence of eight months because the court viewed him as “seduced” by Rudolf. Toni served the first months of his sentence in the court prison in Eger and the remainder at the military prison in Torgau/Brückenkopf. He survived the war and later moved to Essen.

Rudolf, on the other hand, was remanded in "Schutzhaft", or protective custody, the first measure leading to his deportation to a Konzentrationslager. Rudolf served his sentence, but authorities transferred him to Buchenwald concentration camp on August 8, 1942. He remained there until its liberation on April 11, 1945. While in the camps, gay men were often treated badly – many people died from exhaustion due to heavy labor; others were castrated; and some subjected to other gruesome medical experiments.  Rudolf was prisoner number 7952 and like most of the “Rosa Winkel Häftlinge” (pink triangle prisoners)[4], started with forced labor at the stone quarry, prior to being posted to a lighter task in the quarry's infirmary. Several months later, he was assigned a less dangerous job in a construction detachment, as a roofer part of the "Bauhof" kommando, in charge of maintaining the numerous buildings that constituted the camp (dormitories, barracks, administrative buildings, armament factories, etc.

He only survived his imprisonment in the concentration camp thanks to this promotion in the “camp hierarchy” with the help of various Kapos.[5]  Rudolf’s favored treatment was rare as most guards viewed gay inmates as the least favorable. For example, as the war was winding down, before a ‘death march’ to another camp, a kapo spared Brazda from the possibilty of dying along the way by hiding him in a shed from the other guards. Brazda stayed hidden there for a few days, next to the pig sty, until the camp was liberated by the Americans on April 11, 1945. Rather than staying in Germany or returning to Czechoslovakia, he settled in Mulhouse (Alsace, France). Toni regularly visited Rudolf in Alsace. But his attempts to reestablish his old love failed, because Rudolf had found a new boyfriend with whom he lived for the next fifty years the quiet life as a free man.

However, this was not the case for all gay survivors of Nazi persecution. After liberation the Allies did not immediately remove the Nazi-amended Paragraph 175. Neither they, nor the new German states, nor Austria would recognize homosexual prisoners as victims of the Nazis – a status essential to qualify for reparations.  Like most other victims of persecution, reparation was also important to Rudolf. On April 6, 1988, he applied for compensation under the newly created hardship provision of the General War Consequences Act. The office did not process his application. After nine months, they informed him that “according to § 5 of the guidelines, the applicant must have German citizenship”. Although Rudolf was born and raised in Germany, he never received German citizenship and now had been a French citizen since the early 1960s.

Rudolf was not satisfied and appealed the decision. It was not so much about the money, he wanted to recognition as a victim and satisfaction for “what I went through.”  He “only wants the compensation that all those who are eligible have received.” In its reply, the Freiburg Regional Tax Office showed understanding for Brazda's “difficult fate,” but could only explain to him the completely hopeless legal situation. Rudolf did not respond to this, which the office interpreted as a withdrawal of his application.

When Rudolf heard about the upcoming construction of the Berlin “Memorial to the Homosexuals Persecuted under National Socialism” in 2008, he contacted the Berlin Lesbian and Gay Association, traveled to Berlin for Christopher Street Day in June 2008 and visited the memorial together with Berlin's Governing Mayor at time, openly-gay Klaus Wowereit. That was a certain “satisfaction” for him. Brazda devoted the rest of his life to telling his story and encouraging future generations to remain vigilant against hatred and prejudice. In 2010, he attended the unveiling of a memorial plaque in honour of Pierre Seel, who had also experienced persecution by the Nazis for being gay. For speaking out about his experience, Brazda was awarded the gold medals of the cities of Toulouse, Nancy and Puteaux, and was appointed Knight in the National Order of the Legion of Honour in France in 2011.

Together with the historian Alexander Zinn, Rudolf compiled his biography, published in April 2011. Rudolf died on August 3, 2011, at the age of ninety-eight in a nursing home in Bantzenheim (Alsace, France). He was the last known concentration camp survivor deported specifically for same-gender attraction.


[1] the German law that criminalized homosexuality

[2] American-born French singer and dancer known for her risqué performances,

[3] Derogatory term for gay men

[4] In the concentration camps gay men had to wear a pink triangle on their uniform as identification.

[5] Prisoner in a Nazi camp who was assigned by the SS guards to supervise forced labor or carry out administrative tasks.

Sources 

http://rosa-winkel.de/biografien.htm

https://www.stiftung-gedenkstaetten.de/en/themen/online-ausstellungen/rosa-winkel/homosexuelle-haeftlinge-in-den-konzentrationslagern-buchenwald-und-mittelbau-dora/rudolf-brazda

Holocaust Memorial Day Trust.  https://hmd.org.uk/resource/rudolf-brazda/

Hevesi, Dennis. „Rudolf Brazda, Who Survived Pink Triangle, Is Dead at 98,“  The New York Times. Aug. 5, 2011

Zinn, Alexander: "Das Glück kam immer zu mir". Rudolf Brazda – Das Überleben eines Homosexuellen im Dritten Reich  „Luck always came to me“. Rudolf Brazda - The survival of a homosexual in the Third Reich), Frankfurt am Main, 2011.